You are viewing the Serious Explorations Archive.
Click Here to view our message board.


View Full Version : Mercon V vs. Mercon for the transfer case - question


BigE
07-11-2005, 08:12 AM
Mercon V vs. Mercon for the transfer case – local shop that I am looking at to flush the transmission and drop the pan and replace the filter will also do the transfer case, but says that they will use Mercon V for both the transmission and transfer case – manual says Mercon in the transfer case and Mercon V in the transmission – from my research I am lead to believe that you can not interchange the two - shop owner says you can not use Mercon in place of Mercon V, but you can use Mercon V in place of Mercon – Don’t know why Ford had to make this process so confusing – does anyone know the right answer here? Is it OK to drain the transfer case and refill with Mercon V?

Also, is the purchase of transmission fluid from one of the major oil companies (e.g. Mobil, Exxon, Havoline, etc.) that sell it as Mercon V compatible OK? I notice that many are marketing their products as fully compatible for Mercon V, Mercon, and Dexron III, manufacturers transmission fluid requirements.

BigE
07-11-2005, 08:15 AM
Note: The above posting is for a 2000 Explorer Sport 5 speed automatic transmission

Lee S.
07-11-2005, 08:37 AM
I asked this very question a while back:

http://www.explorerforum.com/forums/showthread.php?t=100074

I decided to drain the Mercon V that I had put into the transfer case by mistake and replace it with Mercon. I really don't know why Ford calls for Mercon V in the tranny and regular Mercon in the TC but I figure there must be a reason... so I went with what they called for.

Lee

awhughes
03-23-2007, 06:55 PM
I changed the TC fluid today with Castrol mercon v atf. The shifts are not the same. It slips into gear sometimes. I noticed this change immediately with the first test drive. Can anyone else describe ther experience and ill effects of using mercon v in the TC? Where the problems resolved with draining and replacing with plain mercon? Note, no problems of this sort prior to this fluid change.

schmidlkofer
03-23-2007, 07:13 PM
thanks for all of the help im only 17 and im just getting into the whole off road thing....i mean i have taken my truck mudding( 87 dodge pickup) and i have learned quite a bit from that piece.

Glacier991
03-23-2007, 07:46 PM
Mercon V came about at about the same time as computer controlled shifts. The desire to make "softer shifts" led to some component application strategies that led to transmission shudder due to the friction properties of the fluid at the clutch surface during application. Mercon V was designed to have friction properties to eliminate this problem. It was also semi synthetic, and quite a bit pricier.

Those friction properties are not really needed in a non modulated computer controlled transmission (or transfer case) but do not hurt anything... except your wallet. That is why V is backwards compatible to III, and also why III does not work in place of V (lacking those special properties).

Why would FORD put V in the tranny and III in the Transfer case? $$. Do the math.... several million vehicles, couple bucks each difference in fluid costs... bingo...big bucks.

I am surprised to hear someone has experienced a difference in the transfer case operation due to V... unless the old fluid was really gunky and what you are experiencing is just clean fluid.

Frankly, given that the TC takes SO little fluid, under 2 quarts, why not go whole hawg and go with a full synthetic?

[I know, stop calling me Frankly].

dickd
10-25-2008, 10:03 PM
Hi Glacier991, re Transfer case, i drained the old oil and filled up with plain Mercon , but ran out, on reading that it is possible to use synthetic in the TC when I do the next Transmission change I will do the same Synthetic to the TC but in the mean time my question, would it hurt to add under 1/2 a liter of synthetic to top up the level now.

Using Valvoline Max Life DIII Mercon currently adding Castrol Transmax Z (fully Synthetic)
??

CDW6212R
10-26-2008, 12:45 PM
Technically Mercon does not exist any longer, it cannot be made by anyone. Only old stock is available for Mercon.

Mercon V is the new standard and requirement for anything calling for Mercon. You can add Mercon V or Mercon(if you have it) to what you have calling for Mercon/Mercon V.

4x4junkie
10-28-2008, 07:39 PM
Mercon fully remains available, it's just now called "Domestic Vehicle ATF" or "Dex/Merc" and names like that. Ford for whatever reason pulled the licensing to call it Mercon fluid.

And FWIW, Mercon V is NOT fully backward compatible, despite what some want you to believe. Older M5OD transmissions do not like V, they start shifting like crap if you fill it with V.

As for the t-case, I can't see V affecting the operation of a 1350 or 1354 case. I can't say yay or nay for the 4405 and others though, not familiar enough with them.

jumpn4jesus
10-28-2008, 07:47 PM
What about for a 92 4x4 5speed ex?
I believe I need T and TC fluid, but don't have a big enough wrench, so I need to go get one.

How much should I put in and also is there a filter or anything that I should change while there?

4x4junkie
10-31-2008, 09:04 PM
'08 is the 1st year Ford actually specifies Merc V fluid for the M5OD in Rangers. Some have said the transmission synchros were redesigned for it around '03, although I've seen people complain of shifting problems with it at least as late as '05.

'92 most certainly will need standard Mercon.

96eb96
11-01-2008, 04:30 PM
I was told by a motorcraft wholesaler to use either:

(special product for our trucks)
http://www.fcsdchemicalsandlubricants.com/dealer/product.asp?product=Transfer%20Case%20Fluid&category=Transmission%20Fluid

or

(yes they still make Mercon!)
http://www.fcsdchemicalsandlubricants.com/dealer/product.asp?product=Synthetic%20MERCON%AE%20Multi-Purpose%20Automatic%20Transmission%20Fluid&category=Transmission%20Fluid

or

regular mercon.

They said Mercon V is not the best choice for an xfer case because of the friction properties. It probably won't kill it but there are better alternatives.

hotrod31
11-01-2008, 05:32 PM
Hello, I have been a ford tech for 15 years, and we now use mercon-v in everything(power steering, transmissions that require mercon or mercon-v, transfercases that require mercon). We can not get mercon anymore for sometime already. thanks

X-Files
11-02-2008, 10:15 PM
I just used AMSOIL Synthetic Universal Transmission Fluid for my 98' Exp sport 's Transfer Case,it's said recommended for • Ford MERCON®,MERCON® V & SP,and Excellent for power steering units that use ATF.... so , nothing confused.

Incal
12-16-2008, 07:31 PM
Mercon V vs. Mercon for the transfer case – local shop that I am looking at to flush the transmission and drop the pan and replace the filter will also do the transfer case, but says that they will use Mercon V for both the transmission and transfer case – manual says Mercon in the transfer case and Mercon V in the transmission – from my research I am lead to believe that you can not interchange the two - shop owner says you can not use Mercon in place of Mercon V, but you can use Mercon V in place of Mercon – Don’t know why Ford had to make this process so confusing – does anyone know the right answer here? Is it OK to drain the transfer case and refill with Mercon V?

Also, is the purchase of transmission fluid from one of the major oil companies (e.g. Mobil, Exxon, Havoline, etc.) that sell it as Mercon V compatible OK? I notice that many are marketing their products as fully compatible for Mercon V, Mercon, and Dexron III, manufacturers transmission fluid requirements.

transfer case fluid is only used to lubricate the gears in the transfer case (since there is no fluid pressure inside of the transfer case) it really shouldn't matter what kind of trans fluid you put in the case

KPT
12-16-2008, 07:42 PM
transfer case fluid is only used to lubricate the gears in the transfer case (since there is no fluid pressure inside of the transfer case) it really shouldn't matter what kind of trans fluid you put in the case

There is a pump in the t-case. Sure nowhere near the pressure in an auto tranny but there is still some.

Incal
12-17-2008, 11:59 AM
i dont know what is exactly in your explorer but my 96 is equipped with the borg warner 4405 transfer case and i can tell you first hand that there is definetly not a pump in the tranfer case... meaning no fluid pressure whatsoever

KPT
12-17-2008, 06:41 PM
There absolutely is a pump in a borg warner 4405. I replaced the one in mine when I had to rebuild the case.

Here's a picture of it from glacier's rebuild thread:
http://www.explorerforum.com/photopost/data/503/DSCN7268.JPG

Incal
02-28-2009, 05:49 PM
that may be called a pump but it does not cause pressure in the case, that "pump" is for lubrication purposes and only transfers fluid throughout the gears.

4x4junkie
03-02-2009, 09:49 PM
that may be called a pump but it does not cause pressure in the case, that "pump" is for lubrication purposes and only transfers fluid throughout the gears.

How is a device that sucks the fluid up from the bottom of the case and brings it up to the top where the gears are not called a pump?? :confused:

Incal
03-02-2009, 10:46 PM
sorry, miscommunication. It is a pump, it does move fluid, but it does not pressurize the transfer case. My point is that, unlike the tranny, the transfer case does not have clutches and such that need fluid pressure to operate since the transfer case is shifted either by the shift motor(electronic) or by the operator pulling the stick(manual). Basically the point of this whole thread is that the fluid that you put in the transfer case does not matter if it is mercon or mercon V or whatever... any transmission fluid will work just fine.

KPT
03-03-2009, 12:57 AM
sorry, miscommunication. It is a pump, it does move fluid, but it does not pressurize the transfer case. My point is that, unlike the tranny, the transfer case does not have clutches and such that need fluid pressure to operate since the transfer case is shifted either by the shift motor(electronic) or by the operator pulling the stick(manual). Basically the point of this whole thread is that the fluid that you put in the transfer case does not matter if it is mercon or mercon V or whatever... any transmission fluid will work just fine.

Um a BW4405 has clutches. While the shift motor switches between high and low range, clutches engage the front output shaft.

The pump does not pressurize the case but it does pressurize the main shaft. There are holes where the fluid comes out to lube bearings and gears.

Anyway I don't think fluid matters. I've run nothing but Mobil 1 in my t-case. It did have the shift rail bore issue at 150k but I doubt that had anything to do with fluid.

IZwack
03-03-2009, 01:09 AM
What he meant to say is that the fluid being pressurized only to move it from point A to point B where it is needed for lubrication, not actual operation of a clutch / solenoid / band combo like in a transmission

rumpledoll
03-03-2009, 09:30 AM
I agree - the ATF style fluid in the T-case is not a sensitive item as it's primary job is gear lubrication rather than the smooth shifting/frictional properties as in an automatic transmission proper.

I also use Mobil 1 Synthetic ATF in my T-case, works very well and has all the low temperature advantages that a synthetic fluid has over a conventional. I wouldn't hesitate to use just about any modern multivehicle ATF in the T-case, although I am partial to fully synthetic formulations.

Rumple

Anyway I don't think fluid matters. I've run nothing but Mobil 1 in my t-case. It did have the shift rail bore issue at 150k but I doubt that had anything to do with fluid.

Engnr
07-27-2009, 05:35 PM
I was told by a motorcraft wholesaler to use either:

(special product for our trucks)
http://www.fcsdchemicalsandlubricants.com/dealer/product.asp?product=Transfer%20Case%20Fluid&category=Transmission%20Fluid

or

(yes they still make Mercon!)
http://www.fcsdchemicalsandlubricants.com/dealer/product.asp?product=Synthetic%20MERCON%AE%20Multi-Purpose%20Automatic%20Transmission%20Fluid&category=Transmission%20Fluid

or

regular mercon.

They said Mercon V is not the best choice for an xfer case because of the friction properties. It probably won't kill it but there are better alternatives.

Many Explorers Transfer Case spec was Motorcraft Mercon XT-2-QDX. In 2007 Mercon was replaced by Motorcraft MERCON® V Automatic Transmission and Power Steering Fluid XT-5-QMC per Ford TSBs for ATF and Power Steering. The TSBs say nothing regarding transfer cases and many Explorer owners manuals state Mercon and Mercon V are not interchangeable for many model years. The new Transfer case spec for 2008-2009 Explorers is Motorcraft Transfer Case Fluid XL-12 Spec ESP-M2C166-H

What is the difference between Mercon V Automatic Transmission & Power Steering fluid (XT-5-QMC) and the newer Transfer Case Fluid (XL-12)? Which is better quality and best for use in Transfer Cases now for all Explorers like 1999 models , 2004 models, ....?

CDW6212R
07-27-2009, 06:33 PM
The Mercon, and more so the Mercon V, those are much more slippery fluids. That works great to reduce chatter, shudder, and other customer complaints, but it is harder for clutches to hold tightly. I don't know the fine details that make each new fluid spec different. Like others I try to find expert advice from the fluid experts, and Amsoil is my preference.

The transfer cases in general for Explorers and many SUV's have clutches in them, electromagnetic clutches. I recently noticed in a list of Amsoil fluid recommendations, they now call for a different fluid for the TC of my trucks. They now recommend a fluid that they have had for some time, it's called Torque Drive ATF. That is a special fluid made to meet special standards for a certain Allison fluid in heavy duty applications.

It is a stronger holding fluid than Mercon I and V, so better for our transfer cases. I got a gallon of it recently for my BW4406, for under $40. I may try it in my trans also next time, but 16 quarts is a lot to buy when I already had the other ATF.
https://www.amsoil.com/storefront/atd.aspx

inh
07-27-2009, 07:09 PM
Hrm, wonder what amsoil would have to say about using it in a trans that calls for mercon v... If it's better holding, im all for it =]

CDW6212R
07-27-2009, 07:13 PM
I asked about it for my 4R70W, they told me I could if it was built well(not a slipping shift trans(OEM sloppy smooth)). I'm building a killer trans, but I didn't want to buy another $150 of fluid. So I'll likely try it in another trans.