please post what kit you are using, and on what motor your are using it on. i sold my used EE kit for if i remember correctly around $2000. also, that is used. like you said, if you are going to price things out, then you can price out used cam, heads, headers and still be under a supercharger.
We have a difference of opinion that's ok. I'll track my expenses in my "Blown Again" thread,
Will Be Blown Again!. I think with injectors, tuner, and blower I will be around $3,000.
This is a quick guestimate:
6lbs $3,000/ 72 horses = $41.66 $3,000/90 ftlbs torque = $30/ftlbs of torque
9lbs $3,000/108 horses = $27.77/horse $3,000/124ftlbs = $24.19/ftlb.
Cam, Heads, Headers, Exhaust, and Gaskets????????
$2,000/50 horses = $40/pony and probably about the same for torque. No way will you get the torque from a cam that you can with boost.
Build for torque! At 9lbs the cost per horse and ftlbs of torque is way lower in price. I challenge you to show different and show me where you can get 125ftlbs of torque from a head swap, cam change and exhaust on an Exploder????????