Dismiss Notice



Register Today It's free! This box will disappear once registered!

Which engine lasts longer? 4.0 OHV or 5.0?

Discussion in 'Explorer Related Polls' started by Rick, October 21, 2017.

  • Searches ExplorerForum.com
    ?

    Which engine lasts longer? 4.0 OHV or 5.0?

    1. 4.0 OHV

      4 vote(s)
      28.6%
    2. 5.0

      10 vote(s)
      71.4%
    1. Rick

      Rick Pumpkin Pilot Staff Member Admin Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      February 8, 1999
      Messages:
      30,351
      Media:
      40
      Albums:
      4
      Likes Received:
      337
      Trophy Points:
      113
      City, State:
      Wayoutin, Aridzona
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      '93 XL Pumpkin Edition
      Callsign:
      AB7FH
      I know we have a lot of members with 300k+ on their 4.0 OHV V6s, but do the 5.0s last that long too?
       
    2. Support EF

      Join the Elite Explorers for $20

      Explorer Forum has probably saved you that much already, and will continue to save you money as you learn how to diagnose fix problems yourself, and learn which modifications work without having to experiment on your own. Elite Explorer members see practically no ads, can add their own profile photo, upload photo attachments in all forums, and Media Gallery, create more private Conversations, and more. Join Today. Your support is greatly appreciated.


      to hide adverts.
    3. Varsity

      Varsity Don't need no stinkin 4WD...yet Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      January 4, 2011
      Messages:
      603
      Likes Received:
      15
      Trophy Points:
      28
      City, State:
      Chicago Ridge, IL
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      '00 Sport
      Oooo this will be a good one! Very interested to see the results of this, hopefully it doesn't get too heated here though
       
    4. CDW6212R

      CDW6212R Hauls the mail. Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      June 17, 2004
      Messages:
      16,554
      Media:
      3
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      299
      Trophy Points:
      113
      City, State:
      Knoxville, TN
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      98 Limited AWD
      I think they are very similar in reliability. The real factor is the owner or who takes care of it. Any engine not taken care of will use oil, and die sooner than later.

      My newest 98 uses a quart of oil in about three weeks. That's the previous owner's fault, not the engine's, or mine. An engine getting low on oil will not last 300k miles with the continued neglect. Eventually it will end up three quarts low, and the driver will wonder what the new noise is, ... and keep driving it. That's how you kill one of these, or ignore the cooling system etc. I'm keeping up with this 5.0, it's getting synthetic and never gets too low. I'm sure the valve guides and seals are worn, rebuilt heads should solve that this Winter.

      Who is the person taking care of the car, that's the best question.
       
    5. Rick

      Rick Pumpkin Pilot Staff Member Admin Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      February 8, 1999
      Messages:
      30,351
      Media:
      40
      Albums:
      4
      Likes Received:
      337
      Trophy Points:
      113
      City, State:
      Wayoutin, Aridzona
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      '93 XL Pumpkin Edition
      Callsign:
      AB7FH
      Neglected engines rarely go for 300k, so the poll would be about motors which have been cared for.
       
    6. CDW6212R

      CDW6212R Hauls the mail. Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      June 17, 2004
      Messages:
      16,554
      Media:
      3
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      299
      Trophy Points:
      113
      City, State:
      Knoxville, TN
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      98 Limited AWD
      There are many variations of care, not just good or bad. I could get a million miles from most good engines, if I bought them new.

      Great example, the 4.0 SOHC is a time bomb, with my care it may go 200k, or 500k, but I'm changing the timing chain components timely, every 75k or so. That engine isn't fair to compare with, because those parts would fail way before 300k with normal care(not neglect, simply proper care like anyone who brags they've got 300k from any engine). Only a replacement schedule of care can keep those going for a long time.

      Most people skimp on care at some point in time, using cheap oil, or let it go 7k by accident, or forget to do coolant hoses for too long(and it blows a hose or overheats etc). The 4.0 and 5.0 engines are great engines, they do tolerate more than fragile engines like the 4.0 SOHC.
       
    7. boominXplorer

      boominXplorer Elite Ranger Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      September 16, 2002
      Messages:
      8,040
      Media:
      55
      Albums:
      3
      Likes Received:
      192
      Trophy Points:
      83
      City, State:
      Virginia Beach, Va
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      00 4x4 Mounty
      Every explorer 302 I've had over 250k had to at least have 10w40 oil in it to keep oil pressure at idle.

      I have not owned as many ohv 4.0s but I've seen a bunch in the junk yards with over 250k. I've seen a few that were very neglected with over 200k still running like a champ. Same can be said for the 5.0 but I feel people use v8 trucks harder.

      My vote is that the v6 ohv is better in all around longevity with given circumstances.

      The 4.0 sohc will only make it to 300k after being pulled apart a time or two for timing guides even with synthetic oil changes every 3k.
       
    8. Rick

      Rick Pumpkin Pilot Staff Member Admin Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      February 8, 1999
      Messages:
      30,351
      Media:
      40
      Albums:
      4
      Likes Received:
      337
      Trophy Points:
      113
      City, State:
      Wayoutin, Aridzona
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      '93 XL Pumpkin Edition
      Callsign:
      AB7FH
      Which is why the poll is for 4.0 OHVs and 5.0s ;)
       
    9. Centaurus5.0

      Centaurus5.0 Elite 5.0L Fiddler

      Joined:
      April 15, 2016
      Messages:
      598
      Media:
      41
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      116
      Trophy Points:
      53
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      1996 5.0L 2wd
      Trick question Rick!

      Since they are both the same pushrod design with no real inherent flaws, I'd say it's a tie. The biggest difference would come down to transmission options. A 4r70w can take 250,000+ miles of hard abuse if the fluids where changed at least once or twice. 4.0 transmissions, not so much. The 5.0L also tend to get rode harder either from towing heavier loads or from people not able to resist hammering down to feel the v8's power. Modern synthetic oils and surface conditioners make things like bearing, ring, oil pump, lifter bore, etc wear virtually none existent. Never heard of a timing chain break, just stretch a bit, but they will both keep on a ticking none the less. I guess it comes down to how long it takes for a valve spring to snap and how long you can ignore a seal or gasket (like a rear main and oil pan) leaking onto your driveway.

      I voted 5.0L because.....well, just because. :D

      :burnout:
       
    10. CDW6212R

      CDW6212R Hauls the mail. Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      June 17, 2004
      Messages:
      16,554
      Media:
      3
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      299
      Trophy Points:
      113
      City, State:
      Knoxville, TN
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      98 Limited AWD
      Getting picky, the 4.0 has a few less parts, and the 302 parts are much more available, in stock or tons of choices different forms. The parts are good solid stuff, not overly taxed by big power or rpm's. The pistons are weak links if you try to upgrade parts, but most people don't alter much at all for either engine. It should come down to usage that the transmission has to survive, and the care they get.
       
    11. Centaurus5.0

      Centaurus5.0 Elite 5.0L Fiddler

      Joined:
      April 15, 2016
      Messages:
      598
      Media:
      41
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      116
      Trophy Points:
      53
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      1996 5.0L 2wd
      Had a friend who had Trickflow head, intake, cam with a s-trim on a stock100,000 miles short block that dyno'd a hair over 550hp. The block ended up ripping completely in two. Bad tuning is what ruins pistons.

      I remember Lidio made a point when he had 21psi on a stock 97 cobra engine and ran it all season (high 9's, over 50 passes at 8,000rpm with a 4r70w) with no issues when people said the stock hypereutectic pistons wouldn't be able to handle that amount of power and boost.
      http://www.alternativeauto.com/10_inside_our_9_second_dohc_32v_stock_pistons_and_all/

      I have heard of the stock rods stretching and rod bolts breaking on motors that continuously see +6,500rpm.

      The pistons are the last thing Id worry about on a 5.0L
       
    12. boominXplorer

      boominXplorer Elite Ranger Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      September 16, 2002
      Messages:
      8,040
      Media:
      55
      Albums:
      3
      Likes Received:
      192
      Trophy Points:
      83
      City, State:
      Virginia Beach, Va
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      00 4x4 Mounty
      I need to post a pic of a 5.0 piston from an 99 explorer with a "tick". It sounded like a bad rocker arm but boy was I wrong. Top 1/4 of the piston down to the ring was just missing. Crazy thing was there was no apparent damage to the head or valves and there was a ton of carbon over top of it showing it had been ran like that for awhile. Truck was all stock but was abused by a high school kid.
       
    13. Centaurus5.0

      Centaurus5.0 Elite 5.0L Fiddler

      Joined:
      April 15, 2016
      Messages:
      598
      Media:
      41
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      116
      Trophy Points:
      53
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      1996 5.0L 2wd
      That's a new one to me!

      Manufacturing defects are also a possibility for any part. Bad injector cause it to lean out and melt it away perhaps?
       
      Last edited: October 22, 2017
    14. Centaurus5.0

      Centaurus5.0 Elite 5.0L Fiddler

      Joined:
      April 15, 2016
      Messages:
      598
      Media:
      41
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      116
      Trophy Points:
      53
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      1996 5.0L 2wd
      Another point:

      Rated mpg:
      4.0=14 city/19hwy
      5.0=13 city/18hwy

      You have the ability to tow more, be more reliable(transmission), more aftermarket parts available(besides headers :(), and have a faster truck with a 5.0 vs 4.0 at little to no expense in overall mpg. That is if you can resist keeping your foot out of it.

      Just a thought.

      But then again trail putting/revving and hill climbing might be a different story.

      Do you trail guys see a big difference in fuel consumption between v6 and v8 on your long outings?
       
      Last edited: October 22, 2017
    15. Mbrooks420

      Mbrooks420 High Voltage. Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      February 2, 2002
      Messages:
      5,751
      Media:
      3
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      117
      Trophy Points:
      73
      City, State:
      Erie, Pennsylvania
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      1998 Mountaineer AWD
      My first 5.0 had 220k on it, with zero engine related failures, 20k oil change intervals, constant rev limiter bouncing, neglect, and plowing. No noises, or oil leaks, and would make the 10k mark when the filter was changed without having to add oil. Very stout.

      Undoubtably the 4.0 is also a very long runner.
       
    16. MrQ

      MrQ Take the Bull by the Horns Moderator Emeritus

      Joined:
      October 5, 2008
      Messages:
      2,272
      Media:
      3
      Likes Received:
      9
      Trophy Points:
      48
      City, State:
      Stafford, TX
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      '98 Eddie Bauer
      Callsign:
      MrQ
      5.0, mainly because of the better tolerance for heat, plus they are tough as all get out. If you run a 4.0 even a little hot it'll blow a head gasket without a second thought. Other than that they are solid engines, under powered, but reliable.
       
      • Like Like x 1
    17. Centaurus5.0

      Centaurus5.0 Elite 5.0L Fiddler

      Joined:
      April 15, 2016
      Messages:
      598
      Media:
      41
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      116
      Trophy Points:
      53
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      1996 5.0L 2wd
      Did I mention 5.0L Explorers get a "V8" emblem and the 4.0L don't?


      [​IMG]

      Fun Fact! Henry never posed for a picture with a V6.

      Point: V8
       
      Last edited: November 22, 2017
      • Like Like x 1
    18. damarble

      damarble Active Member

      Joined:
      June 20, 2008
      Messages:
      741
      Likes Received:
      15
      Trophy Points:
      18
      City, State:
      Washington
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      01 Sport Trac 5.0L manual
      From what I've seen 300k is the general upper limit for most OHV 4.0s and 300k should be the expected life for a 5.0.


      It's pretty well known that after 500hp from a 5.0 you're playing with fire.

      What a 4.6 piston is capable of does not make an argument for or against a 5.0 piston.
       
    19. Centaurus5.0

      Centaurus5.0 Elite 5.0L Fiddler

      Joined:
      April 15, 2016
      Messages:
      598
      Media:
      41
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      116
      Trophy Points:
      53
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      1996 5.0L 2wd
      I was pointing out to CDW that the factory Ford hypereutectic pistons are not a weak link, which I believe was what he was referring to when saying they are the weak link. I forget to mention my friends Mustang was a 93.

      All Ford ecoboost engines come with hypers, 5.0L TI-VCT has hypers, 4.6 SOHC and DOHC have hypers and there are too many people running "street boost" with them reliably (+500hp) to say they are THE weak link but I guess you can also reason they most defiantly are a weak link if you have a bad tune in which case the tune is the weak link and a blown engine is the effect.

      That's all I was saying.
       
      • Like Like x 1
    20. CDW6212R

      CDW6212R Hauls the mail. Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      June 17, 2004
      Messages:
      16,554
      Media:
      3
      Albums:
      1
      Likes Received:
      299
      Trophy Points:
      113
      City, State:
      Knoxville, TN
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      98 Limited AWD
      I understood the comment, I call the pistons a weak link because most guys doing performance upgrades don't have perfect tunes. They may get there eventually, but they basically all start out with their old tune and see how it runs. The last thing they worry about is the final tune, to them that's part of the finishing touches. The weak hypereutectic pistons don't like poor timing or fuel mixtures. Yes they are way stronger than cast pistons, and will handle hundreds of HP of normal fuel/timing.

      But forged pistons live better with bad tunes, they aren't immune but much stronger. I expect to find out how the Explorer pistons like 400hp before I upgrade the engine. I would not build an engine combo with mild or more boost for long term use, without forged pistons. That's what I meant by watch out for the stock pistons, the audience being young novices who don't know enough about boost and piston quality.
       
      • Like Like x 1
    21. delexploder

      delexploder Elite Explorer

      Joined:
      March 11, 2012
      Messages:
      1,874
      Likes Received:
      55
      Trophy Points:
      68
      City, State:
      Greenwood De.
      Year, Model & Trim Level:
      97 ford explorer sport
      bottom end on both 4.0s is pretty bullet proof , i know of several pushing 400,000 , thats with valve train refurbished in the ohv and guides and tensioners in the sohc , as for any sbf the bottom end just cant hold up as well , although its a close race , with that said if you are building either of the ohvs some simple oiling mods will greatly improve longevity, i vote 4.0 ohv
       

    Share This Page







    We Support Our Troops!