oh boy, here we go again. Actually, what I got from comments made by Rick, on the last "no cats" thread I commented on, was that as long as it pertained to off-road use, the discussion would be allowed. I also saw a post somewhere, recently, where the poster, in another country, said it was perfectly legal where he was. Given that this board is international, it's mighty presumptuous to assume that it is illegal everywhere.
Further, the poster above me (jonlax) (guess I should have "replied"), and anyone else inclined to make similar comments:
A.) You keep perpetuating this myth engines "need" backpressure. It is ABSOLUTLEY UNTRUE! NO 4-cycle gasoline engine currently used in any road going vehicle, that I am aware of, needs backpressure. It is always a bad thing (restricting topend power, and, usually low end as well). Yes, a bit of backpressure may boost very bottom end torque a tiny bit, but it is almost always offset, and then some, by losses throughout the rest of the powerband. The only exception might be an engine that never revs past say 1,500 rpm or so, due to some other mechanical restruction/design issue. While that may be the case with some diesels, I can't see any modern gas motor being limited to this low of an rpm. Therefor, reduced backpressure will always improve overall AVERAGE power, over the entire useful operating range.
Now, with that said, and probably where the misconception comes in, is that engines DO need adequate exhaust gas flow velocity to optimize exhaust scavenging. This is why simply hollowing out the cats is counter productive. It creates a large expansion chamber, slowing exhaust velocity, and hurting performance. On the other hand, simply replacing them with an appropriately sized length of "straight" pipe will, almost always resut in reduced pumping losses, and imporved performance and/or economy.
Now, as to the "preaching": really, I think it's been said enough. Of course anyone asking about it likely knows the legalities involved. If you don't like it, fine. Don't do it, but really quit the "preaching". Particularily since many of you swearing that it is pointless have probably never actually tried it. Further, the actual removal of the cats is not nesc. illegal. The issue is if it increases tailpipe emmissions. If you had the desire/money to pay for a certification test on a "cat-less" vehicle, and it didn't result in increased tailpipe emmissions, over stock, then it would be perfectly legal. Oh, and yes, with the right combination of tuning,and impeccable vehicle maintenance, it may very well be possible to accomplish that.
Besides, how do you know that this isn't a "desert racer" he's talking about building? Don't ask, Don't tell!