It really depends what your anticipated vehicle usage will be. Street driving? Off-road?
I do 100% street driving and the things I want in a tire for my '01 EB and '00 Mountaineer are:
- Comfortable ride
- Long thread life
- Attractive raised white lettering on the sidewall
For me the Michelin LTX M&S has been my tire of choice. IDK if this model is still available (they're not an inexpensive tire) and I heard they were being discontinued, but I'm sure Michelin has replaced them with something similar. Would definitely buy them again.
For my '01 Sport Trac my tire needs were different. I wanted something inexpensive, long wearing and rugged looking. I chose a set of Fuzion light truck tires. The ride is pretty stiff, they're a bit noisy at 35-45 MPH and the although they have raised white lettering it's kind of ugly, so I mounted them with the lettering on the back side. Would buy them again.
If you just want an expensive tire for street use that rides, handles and wears quite well, I've had good luck with StarFire's (make buy Copper Tire) for around $85 a piece.