I am switching from that exact style console over to a long console myself. For the short console though I have, I got an arm rest from a early/mid 90's ranger console, stronger then the original. Fits the same, and is built better, it has held up fine for me. I would do what ncranchero says though, the earlier short consoles are better. No bag to deal with, and you have the open storage space in the earlier short console.