It doesn't matter what you use at all. The only think you need it to do is weigh down your panels so they won't shake. You could use whatever you want, in whatever form. The sprays and pastes are nice because you can add more to certain areas if you want, but then it's more difficult to apply and not as neat. Car audio competitors have filled their doors with lead and concrete even.
There is generic "Dynamat" as well. At partsexpress.com, you can get all these types. The smaller sheets are about the same price, but if you get the larger rolls, like the 32"x54" then it's cheaper. If you get multiple rolls they give you more discounts. The 32x54 is like $17.90 (part# 268-020).
The super generic low budget method is nothing more than industrial roofing material (such as Iceguard) which can be had for a few bucks, but then you're taking home enough for probably 4 or 5 cars. However, this is a highly based asphalt ingredient and your car will smell like asphalt for a while from two weeks to a month.
The paste offers twice as much damping ability because it's a little heavier, but mostly because they'll tell you to put about twice the thickness of the thinnest version of Dynamat, so it's really just the same. If you break down the glamrous descriptions here's what you get: "A mineral-filled polymer (made of many "ingredients") that transforms vibration into thermal energy with an aggressive adhesive." What does this mean? It means the stuff is really sticky, it has asphalt rocks in it, and since energy cannot be created or destroyed (due to the laws of physics) any moving energy will be absorbed and transormed into heat, but that would happen with anything, it could been Jello Pudding and the laws of physics would work on it. It's the exact same way Microwaves work in essence. You put food in, and electrons are shot at it, absorbed by the food which causes heat.
There's your physics lesson for the day too!
Just use whatever you feel most comfortable with, and that won't break your bankbook.
Jon
[Edited by JTang on 11-27-2000 at 11:15 PM]