I like it!!

Looks so much better in my opinion.
Not to discourage you or your work, but I'll second the paint idea too. I plasti-dipped my bumpers as well and after one rainy day and a couple of puddles later, the plastidip was hanging off my bumpers like a black garbage bag. I have the cheap plastic bumpers as well. I absolutely hate Plasti-dip and the time I wasted.
But it still looks awesome. Let us know how it holds up!