Now, I don't want to contradict anyone about anything. But, I will say, that the one key I notice between Aldive, Billy and CDW is that both Aldvie and Billy, you have 4.0's, while CDW has a 5.0, like me. It would not surprise me if the 5.0 ran significantly hotter than a 4.0... I've had a 4.0 Ranger and can attest to the immense size difference as well as heat difference, the 5.0 definately puts off A LOT more heat than the 4.0.
My judgement, I am going to do the testing as I originally planned. Go down to my Mechanic Friends place, drive around harshly with the stock thermostat and see what temp the X runs at (according to the OBD-II which is all that really matters), then toss in the 180 and see what it reads (assuming that with the 195 its not running dead at 195 all the time, if so, then I will just install a 195).
Also, on a side note... has anyone with a 5.0 X found or tried to find gaskets that work on the collectors? I have had a nasty tick, part of which I know is the Exhaust Manifolds, but I also know a large part of it is the collectors. When I got new Manifolds from Ford (under Warranty), the Collectors no longer matched up perfectly. Ford re-adjusted them about 20 times, every time the engine would sound great for a day or two, then the nice rattle/shake/paper sound would come back. The last time they did it, they put some Sealant on the fitting, worked great for 3 1/2 days, longer than anything else. And the X was dead quiet the whole time... but after all was said and done, it now sounds noisier than ever.
its now to the point that its affecting engine performance and (I believe) throwing off my O2 sensors ( I have a weird problem where the X runs horribly Rich when Cold, but then Lean when warmed up).
Anyways, I am trying to find a Collector Gasket that can seal this up. if I can't, I may just have to have new collectors welded on, but I'm hoping it won't come to that.
I did notice that Summit Racing has a couple of 2-bolt collector Gaskets, 2 are made by SCE and come in a 2" and 2 1/4" inside diameter. The other is in their latest catalog on page 67, right hand column, 1/2 way down. Its made by Flowmaster and is listed as "Ball Style Collector Gasket, 2 1/2" conical" for $6.99.
Does anyone have any experience with this or has anyone had this similar problem and found a good solution? If so, I would greatly appreciate it as I don't really have the $$ to go blowing on $300 worth of Exhaust work, but if that's what it takes to keep the X running another 90k, so be it.
Thanks again guys for all your help, this board is great.