Just replaced my housing also, and the o-ring on the old sensor was totally flat, but it still fit the old housing ok. The new housing o-ring hole must be a slightly different size (larger,) because I dropped in the old sensor and it was really loose at the top and bottom of the sensor hole. So I put a new o-ring on the old sensor, and it fit's the bottom kinda snug, but is still a little wiggly at the top. Doesn't leak as far as I can tell so far. I also had purchased a new sensor, but it was too tight to push in and get the clip on, so I reverted to the old sensor with the new o-ring. Still a work in progress, checking for leaks. I might use a little tape at the top and bottom of the sensor to get it to fit better.