Hmm... both of you guys are in the northeast. I wonder if there might be a problem with "elemental sulphur" in the fuel that's been distributed up there. Recently, several hundred Shell and Texaco stations in Texas and Louisiana were shut down while the tainted gasoline was pumped out and replaced. Turns out the problem extended all the way to Florida - and I believe other petroleum companies (Exxon/Mobil and Chevron) got some of the bad gas, too.
Shell recently settled a class-action lawsuit in Canada over this issue. Referring to a problem closer to your neck o' the woods, one local newspaper article included the following:
"United Refining Co. of Warren, PA has received complaints from customers about gasoline sold at its Kwik Fill and Country Store gas stations in Erie, PA." Larry Loughlin, vice president of United Refining, said: "It's happening all over the place and the gas is all (within regulatory specifications), so to me, that leads to a faulty (automobile) part."
Sure, Larry. All those fuel sending units go on the fritz at the same time, but it can't possibly be the gasoline causing the problem. GM, Ford, various imports - all affected to varying degrees. What do they all have in common? Let me think....
Definitely look into this possibility; you might be able to file a claim against the petroleum company for your repair costs.