Wow, rust was the first thing to come to mind, but I figured it was a slim chance considering you are in virginia. My 94 explorer, 94 b4000, and my dads 2000 explorer all have/had rusted through valve covers on the drivers side. I had to look for quite some time to find one in good shape. No way I was paying $60+ for a crap steel stamped cover, but as luck would have it an explorer from down south made its way to the junkyard. That was the last first gen explorer our local junkyard had, and got crushed about 2 years ago. Even the 2nd gens are slim. This is a junkyard that I'd bet had a thousand cars or more pre-cash for clunkers and the scrap market crash. Last time I was there they might have a few hundred cars, mostly really old ones they don't want to crush. Scrap is up to $70 a ton so I'm hoping things turn around soon.