The Tux Black is fabulous - lots of "fleck" in the paint and it really sparkles. That being said, it suffers from the same maladies as every other black car (common, hot, hard to keep clean...). The Sunset is definitely an "in person" color - you can not capture it well in print. It is pretty unique and I doubt you would be disappointed with it in any way. the only downside is that it's one of those colors that could get "old" after a while depending on your preferences. My wife had a green Acura that seemed like a good idea at the time, but after a couple of years, I wanted to douse it in gasoline and light it on fire (without her in it, of course...). I think Sunset will age better than that, but consider it. I almost bought my Sport in silver, and I swore I'd never own another silver car, but it just looked so good to me on the vehicle. I do have to give Ford credit for paint colors - they have some nice ones.