Hartman said:
why the hell would you put gear oil in it without taking the cover off and letting the old drain out?
Well a handful of reasons:
1) It's developed a small leak (don't know how long since I've only owned it 2 months). 2) It's never dripped anything in my garage or on the driveway, but you can see some old oil/sludge built around the bottom of the diff. 3) you can visually see that the seal needs replacing.
Thus, while I determine whether I just want to replace the seal and drain/fill or replace more components of the rear end I wanted to have the peace of mind of knowing the diff is full. Like I said earlier, I put in almost a full quart which is over 1/3rd of the capacity.
I have some gear noise so I think the rear end is a little tired. However I have to decide whether it's worth fixing. My guess is with oil in it it'll run for another 50k+ but it'll just make some noise at 40-50 mph (which is BARELY noticable unless there's no noise in the car at all and you're really listening for it).
I will keep my eye on the seal and see if it begins to leak worse. This isn't my primary car, it's my beater/utility vehicle so it only gets driven like once a week and it's typically to home depot, the lake, or to some bike riding place.
Summary: I just wanted the peace of mind to know the differential was full of oil while I decide what I want to do with the rear end. I bought it used so for all I know it could've been near bone-dry which could cause a sieze up. Now I know it's full and I'll likely check the level every time I change oil or until I notice a visual leak.
Thanks again for the help guys!