Ok from a truly engine and what's best standpoint, I have no idea. BUT from a use standpoint here you go, a lot of people here, including me run either the KKM or K&N or other form of conical filter thus removing the factory airbox, we either leave the air blend (like I did) or take it out, either way it's basically ineffective, here's what I have found (keep in mind I live in texas, freaking cold here is anything around freezing, none of this negative degree stuff like the yanks have). in the winter it takes longer to heat up, but honestly my explorer has always taken forever to heat up in the cold. in summer I haven't noticed any difference at all.