Are you using the pad with the red backer?
Make sure you're running the G at about 4, and not using too much product on the pad. If you're using more than this:
You're using too much. It's completely opposite in your mind as to how much product you should be using. The pad itself is doing a lot of the work. If there is too much material on the pad and the fibers "lay down" you won't get correction.
One thing I don't see there is a cleaning brush for the pad. I just use something like this:
CLICK ME
That little brush is way important, it will clean the excess product and fluff the fibers on the pad. I clean the fibers out after every square I do. For example, the front door on my Ex, between the window and the center trim strip, is one square. After I work that spot, I'd clean the pad. Otherwise, the fibers just lay down, and you won't get results.
I was a hard learner (it does take a learning curve on the MFDA system) and used one pad until I figured out that it was saturated with product (passenger rear door, passenger front door, and 1/2 of the front fender) before I put on a new pad, used way less product and did the entire rest of the truck and re-did the other 3 panels again with the next pad. That pic above is after I did 3 panels, it's really tough to grasp how little of the product you use. When I had the pad saturated, it looked exactly like your results, might check that out.
Check
THIS thread out- It's got a lot of info that I can't type twice, or I might get fired for not doing any work today...
