Nope, not unanimous, I would go for the ProComps, cause I got them and they are cheaper ,look better than the BFGs and perform very well. I only have a 2wd, but those tires help out a whole lot in the traction department. went through some mud about 6-12 inches deep, and about 20 yards, and I didn't get stuck in the mud, and I am sure it was because of these tires. I think the ATs are cool too, and cheap. They also have a 50,000 mile warranty. I saw a thing in Four wheeler, I think, that had the ProComp AT's on a superduty which had a camper on the back. Not a topper, but a big camper which could sleep a few people. Anyways, the total weight on all the tires was over 10,000 lbs, and the rating for each tire was 2,500# I think, and they looked fine and they ran them for months and they claimed to have no problems with all that weight on them. But yeah go with the PC's either way. They are cheap and they are great tires.