First two quality choices are Skyjacker or James Duff (not in any order). BUT, they're pricey compared to other lifts.
Between the two you mention, I'd go with Tuff Country based soley on the passenger beam drop bracket. The reason for this is, Tuff country redesigned theirs just like Skyjacker & Duff so it WON"T put a hole in the top of your D35 aluminum diff housing when you stuff the drivers tire in the fender when flexing.
Trailmaster, Superlift, Rough Country, all use a "steel plate" to drop/relocate your stock passenger beam drop bracket (Tuff Country, S/J, Duff, use a completely different design). Because of that plate, rather than a complete beam drop bracket, It WILL & DOES contact the aluminum diff housing. Ask "rino351" about it.
At least Tuff country got the message from lots of Ranger/Explorer owners & did something about it. Trailmaster, Superlift, & Rough Country, evidently don't care. Skyjacker & Duff designed it right the first time.
On the drivers side drop beam, the Skyjacker & Duff brackets are superior in strength to all the others. Skyjackers' bracket is designed with "overkill" but that's a good thing.
I know how money situations go but sometimes it's better to spend more up front the first time then go wheeling & not worry about it.
By the way, on the drivers beam drop bracket (the bracket on the passenger side), I had to weld & gusset it because the "ears" broke off (the part that bolts to the underside of the frame) from wheeling. One of them was a Superlift, the other was a Trailmaster. These are on my wheeling buddys rigs. And yes, they both have holes in their D35 housings from the passenger beam bracket. They both made extended bump stops & epoxied up the holes. However, the drivers side tire does not stuff into the fender now. No upward flex on that corner.
This is what I've experienced over the years with TTB Ranger/Explorer lift kits first hand, It's not "hear say".
If you have to get either Superlift or Tuff country, please go with Tuff Country (your front diff housing will thank you). If you have time to save a little more $$$, go with Skyjacker or Duff.
This is all based on if you wanna wheel it. If it's a pavement princess, you can use any less expensive lift. All it takes is one time off road with a good bounce to punch a hole in the diff housing.
Sorry for babbling on, I'm just trying to save you heartache & spending more money in the future