I will tell you all something.
When I made this thread, it was just to help others find a stronger replacement suspension part. I had full reservations about adding a coil over to it, but after years of not adding it, I thought... Ya know....People realize that these 2nd gen SLA IFS rigs are not hardcore wheeling machines. People make threads for stupid stuff, like a new cup holder, or how to fix a dumb squeak that drives them nuts. Why not include the coil overs to it? Now, I wish I stuck to my guns and never shared them here.
This is why...
99.9% of 2nd gen owners doing the occasional driveway repair, are not skilled fabricators, nor are they hardcore off road enthusiasts, with deep pockets.
The coil over mod is a simple bolt on driveway Mod, with the exception of the gussets. In my mind, it is an upgrade from stock, albeit a pricey upgrade, the trade off is anybody can do it. Everything in this thread is simple bolt on procedure. Only reason I added it.
I do agree with the shock angles, and how they affect the ride. A true vertical mount would be way better, but that means cutting, & welding, and some interesting fabrication to make work. That's an entirely different ballgame, and belongs in a different sub forum.
All we are after, is a ride improvement over the harsh T-bars off road. The coil overs with good shocks, do just that. At least for me, and others I know that have done it. My expectations have always been realistic, full knowing that they would never be as forgiving and articulate, as well as the TTB, SAS, or Long Travel. SAS & LT costs are in the thousands, and triple what the coil overs amount too. For most, that do not want to hack the rig apart, and spend upwards of $5k, these offer an affordable option.
I don't, and most don't, trailer these rigs with mild mods. We use them as a DD, or take them to & from our destinations. That can be a trip to the doctor, or a camping trip to the mountains 1000 miles away. Once you hack it up, and change to an SAS or LT, it has become a trailer queen for long distance trips. Some drive a lifted SAS rig to a local destination, and back, but I can't believe they would do it on a weekly basis or too far from home. They did all that work, spent all that $$, and they want to use it hard, and not baby it, to make sure they get back home. Again, apples to oranges here.
To me, it comes down to what your using your rig for. Are you hardcore crawling & trail riding, moderate trail use, or street only? 2nd gen Coil over's are not for anything above moderate trails with the occasional harder obstacle. They do help going down washboard roads or smaller rock ridden trails, as the better shocks will dampen/rebound better than a stiff T-bar can. I did the swap 8 years ago. Been using the rig for mild trails, and long distance Hwy trips, and they have worked great. They help in big cities with pot hole ridden roads, and help with G-force fatigue for long term operators. They stiffen the front end, and do assist in higher speed road use.
Are they perfect? Nope, not by a long shot.
Is the rig stiff with the high rate springs? Sure is, way stiffer then I like at times.
Does it ride better than stock or just better shocks alone? Hell yeah it does.
Is the 2nd gen a hard core trail/crawler? Heck no.
Can the 2nd gen be modified to handle harder stuff and still have fun? Heck yeah.
Was it worth it? For me it was, but that is a personal preference.
At the end of the day, people have to weight out if this mod is for them, and if it is worth it or not. If we can discuss this from all sides civilly, great, have at it. People can & will learn from it. But... I will not entertain any bashing, fighting or arguing this here. I will simply close this thread for good.