Personal Experience

I LOVE my Scorps!!
The ST is STRICTLY street. I saw some the other day on a Chevy Monte Carlo.
The AT has been an awesome tire for me. Very quiet, awesome traction no matter the surface, and cheap!
I've been wheeling on wet and dry rocks, snow, ice, shallow mud, and soft dirt. Never had to air down for grip and never been stuck because of poor traction. (I HAVE been stuck, but it was always because of hanging the undercarriage on rocks.) I've also SERIOUSLY abused the side walls, and never tore one up.
I spend most of my time on pavement too. Snow, ice, rain, dry, whatever. I've never had problems, even in Colorado blizzards and Texas ice storms.
The only draw back I see is that they wear a little faster than some other tires. But for the price, they're still the best deal. I'd vote twice if I could.
