4.0 SOHC Metal Thermostat Housing Comparison

[donalds]

The clips are the same and the connectors are the same

 

[BoscoMoney]

I know I know. Kind of reviving a dead(?) thread here. But how bout this one guys/gals? It appears to be a mostly one piece.
DORMAN 9021999
Dorman Housing

Eh? Yes, no, maybe?

Oh crap. Maybe this is the wrong place for this. I'm so sorry, I didn't notice this was for 2nd gen.

 

[Floridacatfan2020]

NO

 

[BoscoMoney]

NO

So you bought one and used it and had a bad experience with it? Can you share what was wrong with it? Thanks.
I'm not the owner of South Main Auto so, haven't really had all those bad experiences with the brand. Yet.
The Austek is gone. Disappeared. SKP is still around. Simmons plus tax and shipping? LOL no.

Maybe this is the wrong place for this. I'm so sorry, I didn't notice this was for 2nd gen.

 

[oklagp1200r]

So you bought one and used it and had a bad experience with it? Can you share what was wrong with it? Thanks.
I'm not the owner of South Main Auto so, haven't really had all those bad experiences with the brand. Yet.
The Austek is gone. Disappeared. SKP is still around. Simmons plus tax and shipping? LOL no.

Maybe this is the wrong place for this. I'm so sorry, I didn't notice this was for 2nd gen.

I have had the Simmons on my sport trac for years with absolutely no problems!

 

[Floridacatfan2020]

Sorry - you ask for a yes/no/maybe answe

I would not use it

 

[BoscoMoney]

Looking at the aluminum unit Ford made for the Explorer/Mountaineer it looks like a copy. One to one copy? Well its a Dorman amirite? Honestly I have no idea of the quality or fit.
It is a one piece in that the lower housing isn't a 2 piece like all the other aluminum housings I've seen. The Simmons excluded.
The idea would be to use a Motorcraft thermostat and temp sensor and replace the Dorman parts in it.
It uses a threaded sensor which means a different sensor part number. My research says a Motorcraft DY-1156.
And yeah, why not just buy the Simmons. Well, I'm poor. And even after buying the Dorman and changing out those parts its still 50-60 bucks cheaper for me which would pay for the antifreeze and radiator hoses when I flush out the old coolant.

 

[koda2000]

I have had the Simmons on my sport trac for years with absolutely no problems!

I have also had my Simmons T-Stat housing for 2 years without any issues. It's beautifully made and should last forever. I would not put a Dorman part on any vehicle I own unless there was no other choice available. Dorman's stuff is almost always junk. Even when their parts work the fit is usually off.

 

[Floridacatfan2020]

Just FYI - the clip in sensors are considered more reliable than the screw in - I used a motorcraft plastic one and upgraded to the later year model and had to do some handwork to make it all fit together 8 years ago.

 

[429CJ-3X2]

I bought a no-name aluminum housing from Parts Geek last fall (Sept/early Oct), and it's been working just fine with no leaks. It originally came up on WalMart.com when I was searching, but since it was coming from Parts Geek anyway, I went to them directly. Cost was $50 something. I did reuse my original sensors rather than the ones that came with it. There was no part #, brand, or any other marking on it. It's all polished, not like that Dorman part. Maybe I got lucky, but it fits well with no leaks.

 

[allmyEXes]

@koda2000 koda2000 speaks ! Hey Phil, long time no see...