I have the Underdrive crank pulley and the underdrive water pump pulley. I have NO problems.
I know this is not a debate thread but I have to put my 2 cents in; if you don't mind.
The 4.0 SOHC water pump pulley actually slows the water pump down even more! I'm not sure where everyone is getting that it speeds it back up cuss it doesn't. The only 4.0 SOHC pulley that speeds something back up is the ALT pulley.
So with the underdrive Crank pulley (Smaller than stock), and the underdrive water pump pulley (Bigger than stock, REMEMBER, IT'S ON THE ACCESSORY NOW!!!), you're getting even less drag!
If you want to put extra HP (no, you're not increasing HP you're transferring what you have to the wheels instead of the accessories) to the ground then look into this. It's one of the best mods I did to my 4.0 and I think others will tell you the same.
And about the weight issue. I really don't think weight has much to do with this (As far as gains are concerned). I may be wrong but I think the crank pulley has to weigh almost the same in order work correctly.
The price: remember, I don't think this is going to be just a pulley, but a pulley and a harmonic balancer. It's going to take more machine time to make this than some of the other "just pulleys". A machine requires electricity to run$$$$ as well as a highly skilled operator$$$ (Unless you want to buy from a foreign country) as well as materials$$$ as well as overhead (Paperwork, the bosses salary!) Good ole' quality parts made in the US are going to cost you a little. HP costs. Divide the total price by around 10-15 and you get the price per pony cuss I bet you'll see that gain. Take other mods and do the same. Then make your decision.
I see a couple of guys here trying to help bring something to life. Will it happen?
Okay, sorry...had to say it.