I went up under it tonight when I got home.. looks like it is two-pieces, that's my fault. When I swapped it over I guess I thought it was all one unit.
I think I'm going to first try and replace the Sending Unit - The very end of the assembly with the electrical post on it, for lack of better terms, I'm going to call that the sending unit... To see if that fixes my problem. In the mean time I guess I ought to go ahead and get a real oil pressure gauge and I'll hook it up in line with the stock unit, kinda like you did Ranger..
Can any of you guys that have the additional oil gauge recommend me one? Or is it kinda a fool-proof setup where you can pick up a cheap one at Advance Auto.. etc.