Tire Rack had the best deal I could find. My neighbor friend has a shop and he will mount/balance them for free. I need five tires. I tried to order them all together, but they only had four in stock nationwide. The fifth tire is a new old stock from 2020, $28 less than the rest, which are $300.99 each. TR chat guy says they are all the same tread pattern and composition, sidewalls, etc., with maybe some difference in the sidewall markings. The production year doesn't matter to me. He also said I can return or keep the single tire with a partial refund if it's not correct, since it's the last old stock tire they have and they don't want it back. The set of four should be here tomorrow, with the single tire coming on 03/04.
I have used a bunch of tires on the Explorer over the years.
4" Superrunner lift
BFG AT's 32's - decent tire, not great in the rocks, got noisy and started cupping with wear.
Yokohama Geolander MT's 32's - good in the dirt, wore out crazy fast and very noisy.
Mud King 32's - good tire in mud, rocks, snow, etc., noisy. Nothing bad to say about them as they were cheap and worked. A copy of the old style BFG MTR. I traded them for some welding work when I went to 35's.
5.5" lift
Goodyear MTR 35's - great tire in mud, rocks, snow, lasted ten years, got noisy over time. Discontinued or I would have gotten them this time.
5.5" lift and SAS
BFG MTR KM2's 35's - good tire in mud, rocks, snow, small sizing, got real noisy over time. Would have gotten KM3's in a 37" this time, but they are stupid expensive and I would need new wheels.
Post SAS
Maxxis Razr 35" - best tire in mud, rocks, snow, started out noisy and went up from there, almost a 36" tire with a very wide tread compared to the others, wore out stupid fast, expensive. Would only purchase again if I trailered the Explorer everywhere and the price dropped.
Now General Grabber X3 35" - TBD
We discussed this before. I would like to have gone up to 37's but it's just not worth the extra money. The tires are about $150 more each, plus I would need new 17" wheels because no one makes a 37x15 wheel. That would at least double this purchase price and would add 50% more to every future tire purchase. The 35's take me anywhere I have wanted to go. The 37's would only add an inch of ground clearance, with no other real gain, and possibly a slight loss in power. They would look way cooler though, which as I get older becomes less and less of a factor, so 35's it is.